Skip to main content

tv   Erin Burnett Out Front  CNN  April 16, 2024 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT

4:00 pm
senate. mayorkas was narrowly impeached in february in the house. the first time that's happened to a cabinet secretary in nearly 150 years, republicans accuse mayorkas of mismanaging the southern border, a charge that department of homeland security rejects. and when democrats say is politically motivated, the democratically senate is expected to dismiss the case quickly or hold a speedy trial that ends without a conviction. highlight some of it let's keep to our viewers, thanks very much for watching. i'm wolf blitzer in the situation room. i'll see you tomorrow, 11:00 a.m. eastern for cnn newsroom. and then tomorrow night, 6:00 p.m. eastern right ear in the situation room until then, once again, thanks very much for watching erin burnett outfront starts >> right
4:01 pm
>> i'll front next breaking news seven jurors just seated for trump as trump gets scolded by the judge for intimidating a juror the court sketch artist who was with trump all day is out front, was biden hits the campaign trail in a big way, slamming trump's courtroom cameos as are harry enten breaks down the numbers showing where biden is gaining ground tonight. and this may surprise you and payback cnn learning israel is now considering a strike inside iran, us ambassador to the united nations, linda time thomas-greenfield responds to go out front good evening. i'm erin burnett outfront tonight, fast and furious the first seven jurors who will be deciding trump's fate have now been sworn in for trump's new york criminal trial. there were zero jurors this morning, seven tonight that is zero to seven. and i mean, the case is accelerating fast jury selection is now more than a
4:02 pm
third done, and the judge in the case told those who have been sworn in to be ready to go on monday. >> now, excuse me. that is week sooner than most experts had expected. so let's just go through what we know now about the first juror seated f for trump's historic trial the first juror will be the foreperson. he's originally from ireland, reads the new york times, the daily mail watches fox and msnbc the second juror is a woman an oncology nurse, reads the new york times and watches cnn the third juror is a corporate lawyer originally from oregon he is not married and has no children. he gets his news from the new york times, the wall street journal, and google the fourth juror is identified as a puerto rican man with an it business, and he told the court that trump quote, makes things interesting. it says he has no strong feelings about politics. >> the >> fifth juror is a black woman who was an english teacher. she told the court she is not a political person and really doesn't care for the news and the sixth is a software engineer who recently graduated college. she said she gets her
4:03 pm
news from the new york times, google, facebook, and tiktok and number seven, a lawyer originally from north carolina who told the judge he has quote, political views as to the trump's presidency and thinks that there were policies he disagreed with now, this is the seven we've got. this is what both sides with everything have agreed to. so that gives you a portrait of who's in that room. when these jurors walked to the jury box, some did appear under stress der three biting his lipped are six kept her eyes on the ground. trump did react during the der or questioning. we understand from our reporting in the room, the judge actually raised this voice after he heard trump monitoring and the judge said, merchan, i won't tolerate that. i will not have any jurors intimidated in this courtroom. >> i >> just moments ago, trump left. he spoke out to the cameras and lashed out at the judge we are going to continue our fight against this, judge. we think he's totally conflicted he's are conflicted
4:04 pm
judges you over an appeal now in a moment i'm going to speak to the sketch artist who is in that courtroom next to trump all day. and first i want to begin though with beringia and grass, who is out front at live outside the courthouse and bring the jury selection today. i mean, after yesterday, i actually know when was it? two 30 this afternoon, nerve 3:00 someone told me they've gotten nobody still don't have a single juror and then all of a sudden, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. and we've got seven. yeah. i mean, what's next and what this mean for the trial timeline? >> yeah erin i mean you make a good point. i think people were really concerned. how do you actually see a jury for a trial just like this, but it did accelerate quite quickly in the late afternoon today. so essentially right now, where we stand like you just laid out, those seven people who are anonymous to the public, only those minor details. and they were told by hi, the judge to not consume any news, to not talk to anybody and to report back for monday. that is when they hope to have opening
4:05 pm
statements for this trial. now, that schedule could change just a little bit and that judge did give a bit of a caveat, but where it stands right now, remember, both sides, the prosecution and the defense, they get ten strikes when it comes to these jurors, will both sides have used six, so they're four strikes remains. so get those five jurors left in the 12th panel. and then of course, there also needs to be alternatives. it's not clear yet just how many alternates the judge wants for this trial, but it was really interesting to see into hear about these ajour rather than the fence and the prosecution using these strikes, there were jurors that were called back in and it was very clear that trump's defense team had gone through their social media challenging some of the posts that they were have. >> they >> had essentially saying that they can't be impartial and unbiased as they had promised in that corner. ordering, for example, one person said that they had a facebook post that said that lock him up and he was dismissed by the judge for
4:06 pm
cause. another person had husbands posts that were a little bit controversial. the judge said that person could be allowed to be on this trial, but they did. that is not the case. so anyway, there were some real really interesting moments as they ticked through these different people trying to figure out who could actually serve on this jury and be impartial and be fair for a defendant like donald trump era is really fast that he just the details. >> right. and then how it works, just individual people walking in and all of this and to see the scouring of the social media all right, brian, thank you so much. outside the courthouse. and i want to go now as promised to christine cornell's, she was in the courtroom today. the official sketch artist today, in addition to this trump trial, christina sketch, many high-profile criminal trials. so she's used to seeing these moments. i'll chatbot the mexican drug lord mobster john gotti, bill cosby, jeffrey epstein bernie madoff wow, you have seen it all and you were there today and i know this was a momentous day. do you a part of history. >> and
4:07 pm
>> in fact, i mentioned all those individuals that you've drawn, but you've drawn trump for decades back to an antitrust suit decades ago. so you've seen this man a change and morph and age in so many different ways >> what did you think today >> he sees gotten a bit older? >> no, i've been drawing him now for months. >> right. but i did draw him when he was a young man he's always kind of startling because of his height. you really isn't big guy. >> and also the kind of impassive mask klette, he wears you know, he's really he's very designed very purposeful. yes, his those eyebrows, you know, which are you know, they they they wear him >> and you do draw them with such distinction. you they really stand out and how you draw him i want to show one of your sketches de, were going through some of them, but this one it appears in this one that his eyes are closed. what was
4:08 pm
happening here? >> my apologies, ma'am. i was sitting 50 feet away. i was having such a struggle to try and get those eyeballs in it was just not the best advantage you know, point to say here. yeah. i mean, later in the day he was more cooperative and he turned a couple of times and knowing that there's someone there in a sense, right? >> we did he could >> know her into your vantage point and see, you know, he wasn't doing anything for me. he was just talking to his attorney was sitting right there on his on his right. all right. ahead. my binoculars on. so any look that he gives it all is going good. i'm going to grab it. yeah. all right. so could you tell what was happening in that moment or no, that's just what just stood out to you. just let me was talking to his >> lawyers about various jurors and what he thought of them this was this was what was unique about this jury. was that first day they called, i think 96 people and i think 50 people raise their hand when
4:09 pm
the judge said raise your hand, if you can't be fair and then today there was a whole little train. the trailing and saying, oh, judge, i slept on it. >> i can't be fair oh, that's what you saw today? yeah. even more, we're dropping like flies so this is this is a unique situation. usually people have all these other excuses. my vacation, my child, my job, this that not in this case, but interesting what you say coming in, i slept on it >> how >> did they react the jurors that you saw when they the ones and i was just going through some of the basics that we know about them, biographical >> but when you >> saw their faces, when they realized they had been chosen, well, they had to walk right past me, which was really quite fascinating. i got the whole down the runway look. and you know, that was the first guy number one, and he was all he was almost militaristic. >> this is the foreperson, the man ireland, real military presence about him there was a
4:10 pm
>> an asian man >> and i remember he was, he was quite contents. everybody felt like they looked as if they'd been hit by a ton of bricks when they heard the news that they were actually chosen one woman went scurrying by and she was smiling >> she seemed happy. she was happy >> yeah. interesting. all right. so let's show another one of your sketches oh, yeah, older man, the one who said that he found trump interest yes. >> i was older. yeah. he was an older guy. i couldn't get over him listening to him say, okay, you've got to stop using that word. interesting, because it really means something else. but anyway, he got selected and i thought, well, we actually have a jury of his peers. this is a guy who's probably close to trump's age. the end there was close to trump so you did see you saw diversity in age most and it sounds like the young ones mostly young, mostly. >> all right. so what was from what you could tell trump's reaction as as these i mean, i talked about a moment where he was muttering. my understanding is that particular jordan end
4:11 pm
up for whatever reason whether it was struck are not on the jury that but what what was trump's reaction? could you tell to anyone who is chosen? >> no, i really could not. you couldn't >> because i'm 50 feet away >> sitting smack dab behind his head. >> so were there other moments that stood out to you when he did turn and you're looking through your binoculars? >> i loved it. i loved it when the judge reprimanded him for muttering because that was the woman who had videotaped celebrations when he he hadn't won the election, right by biden celebrations in new york city right? and i think was beside himself with that piece of information. and the judge scolded him, which i thought was great and it was clear he was he was angry at me. yeah, i need tilted his head back in yemen. he had to agree, tilted his head back and shut his eyes when the judge said that, oh, really, he two okay. and from his interactions with his lawyers, could you tell anything else about i don't know his demeanor or his feeling or his emotion in those interactions >> now you're making me wish i was in the overflow room >> they have did on his face,
4:12 pm
rayyan him, yes >> but it's different in this case. you are because you're in the room, you have the vibe, you have the kind of electricity i was actually to get the feeling for the people, you know, because they really do come from all walks of life it's kind of shocking to see them coming in and you know, and you think, i wonder what trump would think of this one or that one or this one you know, none of them. i don't think are kind of like the his standard of caliber of what he really admires and human beings, which is extremely shallow quality. >> so let me ask you one more thing, because i said you have done you've sketched him over many years, right? l. chatbot, john gotti, bill cosby, jeffrey epstein, bernie made off. you have been in the room at the most notorious defendants, some of the most notorious in new york history. how did this moment compare >> you know, there's a bottom line thing, it's just another human being he's just a guy in a pinch you know and you're there to capture the humanity absolutely >> and you want to see it be a fair trial. absolutely.
4:13 pm
>> all right. well, christine, thank you very much. it's really fascinating and thank you for sharing that. as i say, you become the eyes for all of us of history when you are in that courtroom drawing. so thank you. >> my pleasure. >> and i want to get to all of our experts here with me and just a moment to talk more about all of these details that christine just shared. i want to begin with robert hirshhorn, jury consultant for decades of experience. welcome back, robert. i know you've got the william kennedy smith rape trial. george zimmerman trial in your history of what you've been part of, what do you make of what christine is describing about some of these additional details she shared about these jurors. and their reactions that the foreperson she described as almost militant in when he walked by the man originally from ireland she described an older gentleman, a trump peer in terms of age and a woman who was smiling and seemed very happy to be on the jury. what do you take away from what you just heard? >> it's a it's a mixed group. this is exactly what you want.
4:14 pm
it's you've got people from different walks of life. you can see that i'm wearing my fishing tie today. and the reason i'm wearing it is because the former president called themselves some pretty good jurors today, we've got seven. youve got two of them that her lawyers the end what this sketcher was telling us is that these jurors are reacting naturally it's not just that it's a criminal case, it's not just that it's a high-profile case. it's a criminal case that's high-profile involving most popular person popular, the most well-known person in the world by the name of donald j. trump. and so some jurors are going to be happy about it. some are going to be frightened about it, some are going to just do their job because the key thing that the sketch artist said aaron, when you strip it all away donald j. trump is just another person that's on trial and i'm telling you this jury is going to give the man a fair trial. >> yeah. i mean, it is fasting what she said, right. it is the humanity and when you think about all the people she's been
4:15 pm
in the room, it strips you down to that that you are a human, as i think christine put it in a pinch >> she >> also was talking about the juror that i mentioned, juror number for puerto rican man with an it business who tells the court trump quote, makes things interesting. the way christine described it was that that he said that word a few times and it appeared clear that that word may mean something it was unclear. what do you take away from that? and the fact that that individual has been chosen to be on the jury to me aaron >> are you asking me? yes. yes. yes yeah >> interesting is the perfect word that team trump wants to hear. it can be interpreted all sorts of different ways. i don't think it's a dog whistle for anything. look, i liked the guy. he's just being real and honest and that's what you want from the jurors. he's expressing on the outside what he's thinking on the inside. and that's all we can ask you.
4:16 pm
the people that we are that we summons and send down the courtrooms all across america to serve as jurors. so kudos for him, for being for being so straighten, honest. all right. so robert, stay with me. a paul martin is with me as well. i mean, we're rocha as well. okay. so so so paul, you you've tried to hundreds of criminal i'll trials. another thing that stood out to me from what christine just said is how many peoples xi said. i don't forgot what words you use, but i think it was sort of dripped and in front of the judge to say i slept on it and i decided i can't be unbiased more than half had raised their hands yesterday. but what do you make of the fact that people slept on it and came in and did that what i found was in manhattan, you are going to find jurors are some of the most educated and pathetic knowledgeable individuals. that's great. that's what you want on the jury. you're also going to have a bunch of cracked pots as a defense attorney, our new yorkers, we all know i want a little bit of both as a i definitely want some cracked pots because you only takes one one juror does flip the whole
4:17 pm
button, doesn't. so i think i've respect the fact that they that they came back and they said that they couldn't sit, but it's the ones that were chosen that i thought were interesting >> what stood out to you from what we found out today and also what christine was just sharing the additional details about some of them and their reactions to being chosen very, very serious, but certainly in one case, quite happy. >> yeah, i mean, look, i think even just since yesterday, this is such a different conversation. i mean, first of all, we have sub-zero or seven and one hour or something like yesterday, i think people were oh god, this is going to take three there, four weeks and some of us said no, you know, they'll get into a rhythm. the pace will pick up and it did so i think just that we just have to take a moment and step back and say the process is going forward. it's working the way it works in the hundreds of trials that you've done and the hundreds that i've done or seen and it's it's it's
4:18 pm
remarkable how normally it is. yeah, in this situation. and i think that's worth just saying the criminal justice process, the jury system is working the way it's supposed to apologize, anything stand out to you about when trump was reprimanded? by the judge for muttering and the wake christine described as it was very clear, trump was angry at this juror who had posted a video of people celebrating in new yorkhen biden one and e judge admonished him, she chstine described his reaction is because he had to accept it, but he leaned back and shut his eyes. >> it's not going to be the first time it's not going to be last. >> this is who he is. we should be all be prepared that he's going to act as trump. the question becomes, is he going to do this in front of the jury? and what ramifications is that going to make for the judge? because at some point in time, he's going to push them to a corner where the judge has got to do something serious. >> right. and they're all going to be sitting there now in judgment literally of that robert, may i ask you from zero? this afternoon, as i said, we had no we had no jurors. and then in an hour or
4:19 pm
an hour and a half, suddenly we had seven jurors do youth and they were told to show up on monday as if opening arguments are going to begin, then we don't know exactly how many alternate, you know, you've got to get to 12 and then some number of alternatives, possibly up to 18. no election tomorrow. do you think this is done by friday >> i think there's a good chance. here's the thing we went from glacial speed to the speed of light and the other point i want to make aaron is that if president trump are former president trump were smart, i know he's talking to the face what he makes his comments before and after court. >> but he ought to be talking up. the jury ought to be talking about what great jurors we have. and i appreciate everybody being honest and we just want more jurors to be honest because all i want a fair trial. stop dumping on the judge, stopped whining all the time and just time to talk up the jury. that would be a smart thing for him to do at this point, you're right. >> they are because they are going to make the decision. one other juror, the moment i mentioned who teaches english public school charter system she told the court that
4:20 pm
there's a person of color she has friends who have strong opinions on trump. she personally is not political. she doesn't care for the news she was the only of the 18 questioned this morning who said he was not aware that trump is facing other criminal charges and other criminal no cases. so mar-a-lago, january 6 what do you think that means for trump? >> i think that just makes her frankly, a good der it may not make it may surprise some of us who consume new and information on a daily basis at exhaustion, but think it. makes her good der frankly, for both sides, she sounds like as much of a clean slate basically as they're going to get in a case like this. sounds like she's being quite straightforward about and probably doesn't do a lot of social media, maybe reads only certain aspects of the news, maybe go to the sports section or who knows. and so i think really that she's a good der for both
4:21 pm
sides, which is again, kind of how the jury system works. both sides are going to eliminate or strike the extremes. and we're all humans. so every person comes in, they're with their individual that gold foibles, and that's the reality of the humanity of it all. >> all right, thank you all very much. and we do have major developments tonight in another case that could affect trump and the charges he's facing, the supreme court in session today hearing whether pros in a case here where the prosecutors went too far in charges against the january insurrectionists. this could have huge implications for jack smith plus us ambassador to the united nations, linda thomas-greenfield at the dmz. today, with a big offer for kim jong un we're gonna tell you exactly what it is, why it matters. she's out front and marjorie taylor greene says she does have the votes to oust speaker mike johnson another major republican join getting her fight today >> there are others behind massie as well >> of course, i'll never
4:22 pm
>> speak for them to say their name erin burnett outfront, brought to you by stanley steamer from carpet upholstery air ducts and more. it's not clean until it's stanley steamer clean right now, pet dander skin cells in dirt are settling deep into your carpet fibers. stanley steamer removes the dirt you seen in the dirt, you don't your corporates aren't clean until their stanley steamer clean. >> these name with cargo ruse, filter millions of listings to land the perfect deal only you could do things your way all the time imagine get it with gurus >> okay, everyone our mission is to provide complete balanced nutrition are strength and energy >> ensure 27 vitamins and minerals. nutrients for immune health, and ensure complete with 30 grams of protein >> higher shipping rais, maybe
4:23 pm
the cost of doing business. but at what cost? >> turned shipping to your advantage. >> with low cost >> ground shipping from the united states postal service why choose asleep numbers, smart, bad climate. my side softer, my >> sayyed, firmer sleep number. does that now seep up to $800 on select sleep number smartphone or 0% interest for 36 months. chuck, now it's sleep number.com. >> you open your mailbox and see the envelope from your health insurance company? the knee. you hold your breath. >> will they pay for your >> child's treatment this time? you open the letter and find that you've been denied again a month later, another letter arrived. you've premiums are going up again they are banking record profits and still plan on increasing their rates by 12% how can the health insurance companies get away with this? >> so let's get the rest of these plants. organic
4:24 pm
>> soil from miracle gro has grown me the best garden i have ever had. >> good >> soil and you get good results. >> this soil will blow you away. >> it's the martha >> stewart of soil hey, with priceline vip family, you can unlock deals five times faster. you don't even have to be an actual family. >> i'd be the dad on the day he physically it's clear that i'm the dad. okay. so which data is pain? >> okay. yeah, we got orders coming, starting business is never easy. a star nine, eight months pregnant. that's a different story. >> i couldn't slow down. we were starting a business from the ground up people were showing up, left and right. and so did our business needs the chase e car made it easy. when you go for something big like this, your kids need it. and they believe they can do the same, earn the limit 1.5% cash back on every purchase. but thel
4:25 pm
187, 68555 new tonight the
4:26 pm
supreme court appearing skeptical in a case that could have a direct effect on special counsel jack smith's election interference case against >> donald trump. at issue is a federal obstruction law which has been used to charge a of people accused of taking part in the january 6 ride on capitol hill including a former police officer who is challenging the use of this statute. >> it is a law that >> is also central to two charges in the doj case versus trump. >> so that is at stake. >> so the doj repeatedly was asked by the justices to try to defend why their interpretation of the law was not an overreach would a heckler in today's audience qualify or at the state of the union address would >> pulling a fire alarm before a vote qualify for 20 years in federal prison? >> can you just give us a little bit more? as to why we shouldn't think of this as
4:27 pm
being a narrower set of circumstances to which this text relates >> obviously taking from perceive, you have got to justice. left-leaning and right-leaning skepticism share ryan goodman are outfront legal analyst is with me now and ryan, you obviously say that at linof questioningrom judge tanya brown jackson is very significantright? this isn't just a left-right split. that wsaw onoth sides. ism >> that's ght. and that happens ofteim when we' talking out defendant's rights that it cuts across ideological boundaries, and that the justices and they expressed it today as we just saw, are concerned turn that the law may have been interpreted to broadly and that they want to interpret the law if there's ambiguity in favor of a defendant, there's even a canon of construction the way you're supposed to interpret certain laws is in favor of the defendant. if there's that kind of ambiguity and they both were pressing on that issue. >> all so here's the thing half of jack smith's charges against trump in the election interference case use the same statute. if it gets struck down
4:28 pm
here, not only does have huge implications for the defendants in january 6, you'll hundreds of people have been charged some have said this could be disastrous for jack smith when it comes to trump himself. what do you say? >> so do think it will be very significant for the department of justice because out of the nearly 1,400 people who had have been charged for january 6, a full quarter have been charged for this particular offense, 350 just over three and 50. so that's a huge number that are stands that are at stake for what the supreme court rules. i don't think so when it comes to donald trump's case for a couple of reasons. first, what's really at issue at the supreme court today is whether or not the statute is only about obstruction of records and documents. and mr. fisher, for example, is not charged with that. he's charged with running into the capitol and interpreting what the possibility, right? yeah, exactly. seating. >> so what has trumping charged with documents and records? it's the full certification by the false electors and then hit their submitting that to gamma the works of the congressional proceeding. and in fact, a couple of hypotheticals today
4:29 pm
we're about well, what if it's about the certificates and the answer for fisher's by fishers lawyers. oh, that's actually a larger case, but not our case well, that might actually mean that that's the case. that would be applied to trump. there's the allegations, but this is not a direct precedent setting ruling if they go against it for trump in the doj cases, what you're saying on the face of it, >> that is correct. just now depends on how they write their opinion because they could still write it more broadly if they wanted to and the second is that the indictment by jack smith is very clever and some people will not like to hear this in a certain way in terms of how clever it is. it has all of the allegations of facts. and then at the end it says, okay, here the three charges so you can knock out one of the charges. it's in the alternative. the facts still come in for the other two charges. so maybe they don't have obstruction, but then they have one or the other two like conspiracy to defraud the united states is one of the other two. they'll just say, okay, all of those charges still a plot, that charge still a post, all the same facts. >> all right. well, thank you very much. ryan goodman and next president biden, tearing into trump while trump sits in a courtroom
4:30 pm
>> i look at the economy. i don't see it through the eyes of mar-a-lago i see through the eyes of scranton plus there's breaking news tonight is israel's deciding whether to launch a counter attack inside iran. would the united states supported us ambassador to the un, linda thomas-greenfield will be outfront life diabetes >> there's no slowing down. each day is a unique blend of people to see. and things to do >> that's why you whose lucerne it to help manage blood sugar response uniquely designed with carbs steady glue, sirna, bring on the day >> realtor.com is the >> only site that lets you find homes with assumable mortgages so you could take over the sellers mortgage at a lower interest rate don't all have to do that. not really. go to realtor.com to learn more. >> when enamel is gone, you cannot get it back, but you can repair it with pro will repair it penetrates deep to the two to actively repair acid weakened enamel, i recommend
4:31 pm
for enamel repair with new pronominal repair mouthwash, you can enhance that repair beyond brushing. they were great too yeah, there hello, ghostbusters. >> it's duck. we help people customize and save hundreds on car insurance with liberty mutual >> situation sure. i can do this hcm, is. a serious heart condition affecting as many as one and 200 people >> like me and me, i was still short of breath and my beta-blocker so i talked to my cardiologist and asked about treatment advances in hcm >> that talk made a real difference >> it gave me the whole >> talk to your cardiologist today >> visit atm >> real talk.com to learn more why would i use kayak to compare hundreds of travel sites at once? i like to do things myself. i can't trust anything else to do the job
4:32 pm
right? >> hi, search one and done. >> hi guys, bill, you look great. now that i have inspire, i'm free from struggling with the mask and the hose baryons buyers of sleep apnea treatment that works inside my body with a click of this button where you go i'm going to get in spite learn more and do you important safety information at inspire sleep.com, there are over 7 million us businesses on tiktok. >> i'm sarah as rich and the life merch print director at independence village as senior living community and walkie, iowa >> everybody here and valence really make you feel like family and that they love you are going ball with tiktok was to enrich the lives of our residents. i think i am a tiktok gram. all my kids think i am. >> i mean, we're the ones that are being entertained. time grows faster keep tiktok >> this tiny home trend not for me. now, this is more like the same goes for my footwear. why one hands-free with white fits, are slipping just step in and
4:33 pm
go w
4:34 pm
relief? absolutely free text hello, v0 to three-to-one, three-to-one today >> i'm natasha bertrand at the pentagon and this is cnn >> tonight, president biden going after trump in a big way in pennsylvania, mocking trump's legal problems, even taking on the tanking price of trump's truth, social shares all while trump's spent the day in new york city courtroom was a very stark contrast. and arleigh arlette saenz is out front >> president joe biden tonight, leaning on his scranton, pennsylvania roots to make as economic case against donald trump. >> folks where are we come from matters. when i look at the economy, i don't see it through the eyes of mar-a-lago. i see through the eyes of scranton. >> well, trump's that's another de in new york city courtroom, biden embarked on a three-day swing through battleground, pennsylvania with a pitch on tax fairness. no.
4:35 pm
billionaire is your >> pay a lower tax rate? did a teacher of nerves a sanitation worker >> the >> president took aim at trump's plans to extend republicans 2017 tax cuts, which expired next year biden is vowing to raise taxes on the wealthy and corporations while promising no tax hikes for those making less than $400,000 trickle-down economics fail the middle class it failed america. the truth is donald trump and bodies that failure. he wants to double down on trickled down meanwhile, trump issued his own warning against biden, would have joe biden gets his way, you will soon be facing colossal tax hikes, the likes of which no one has >> ever seen before. >> at times, biden openly mocked his predecessor. >> yes, she other day a defeated-looking guy came up to me and asked if i could help he was drowning in debt i said i'm sorry, donald, but i can't help you >> and jabbed at trump's stock markets stumbles. >> if trump stock, in truth,
4:36 pm
social company drops lower you might do better on my tax plan that is the president made his case near his childhood home in scranton while the campaign used a new digital video to play up his local ties grant and is a set of values we pride ourselves on the importance of family and honesty and hard work. >> the president also is facing a close contest against trump in pennsylvania. were 19 electoral votes are up for grabs in a state critical to maintaining the democrat's so-called blue wall biden this week has tried to shore up support in key areas he want, like here are lack of wanna county home to scranton, but surrounded by counties that went for trump in 2020. and with his eye on november biden warned voters of what could come in a second trump term is common for your money. your health care, and your social security mr.. not going to let
4:37 pm
it happen >> how did the trip president biden sought to draw another contrast with trump by releasing his 2023 tax returns, something trump did not voluntarily do while he was president. the president will continue his campaign, swing tomorrow. with a stop speaking to steel workers in the pittsburgh area. and he'll wrap up the three-day trip in philadelphia on thursday. aaron arlette. thank you very much. in scranton. and i want to go now to harry enten. let's go beyond the number. so harry are let's talk about the tight rais and pennsylvania you have noticed war ticulate group that stands out in that states, yeah if you look at the great lakes battleground states what stands out about them versus let's say the sun belt battleground states is that white voters make up not just the majority of voters, but the vast majority of voters, 80% north in the state of pennsylvania, the commonwealth of pennsylvania. and if you look among white voters, the trend line that you're seeing there is look, donald trump is still winning amongst them. he won them by 12 percentage points
4:38 pm
back i can 2020, but in 2024, that margin has been cut in half. it's not just a six point advantage for donald trump in the state of pennsylvania among white voters. and this is a big reason why joe biden is so competitive and pennsylvania, while it's falling behind in other battleground states like arizona and georgia, and pennsylvania, white voters make up the lion's share of the voters. and joe biden's doing sigma inefficiently better amongst them than he did four years, which is fascinating because it's not a story line people may expect. yes, you talk about biden, you talk about oh, people think the democrats and you're going to have it's about diversity in the base. so that is a fascinating point you say about white voters, but it's not all you're noticing. where else are you seeing gains that may surprise people for biden? yeah. >> if we've been talking about nash surely that joe biden has been struggling among voters of color, hispanic voters in particular. and you look at the aggregate of paul's, what we're seeing there as we are seeing gains for joe biden. so if you go back to february, trump was actually leading. it's amongst hispanic voters by a point. now, joe biden's ahead, he's only ahead by nine points. that's significantly worse than he did back in 2020. but the fact is joe biden is ganim among hispanic voters,
4:39 pm
and that is a big reason why, and the average of national polls, donald trump was ahead two months ago. and now we're looking at a tight race nationally and >> the things we just heard, arlette highlighting when biden saying go for your social security and health care, and it's part of a push biden has been making and towards middle-class voters that he thinks will work, is it >> no? i don't, at least not at this particular point, if you ask voters who they think is better to represent the middle-class, you go back to 2020, joe biden, lead on that metric against donald trump is pretty clear margin. it was seven points back in 2020. you look at the police, now, look at the 2024 pauling, who is better for the middle-class, donald trump leads by nine percentage points this to me more than anything else, sort of encapsulates the problem that joe biden is facing. a lot of voters were looking back on the economy, back during the trump administration. that's it. that's a 16-point sway that is 60 clear. that is a very 16 point swing. it's a very large string, it's one of the largest swings that we've seen across the pulling down, i think is a big reason why donald trump at this point is a much better position than he was and 2020 poland.
4:40 pm
>> all right. >> harry, thank you very much. and there's important information, so let's bring in former executive director of the new york state democratic party, basil smile. so basil let's just start where harry finished >> and then >> there are positives naibe, lets start on that middle-class issue, biden, obviously focusing in on that, that's clear. >> the point that the >> swing though that we've seen thus far is six team points away from biden among the middle-class. that's a pretty stunning things that is that something you can turn around enough >> i think so. you're starting to see as numbers get better in a lot of different places. and i do think that these numbers are turned around. but going back to the state of the union, he talked about these very issues focusing on a middle-class, like a tax break but also taxing the wealthy. he's talked about assistance for homebuyers win in states, particularly states like new york, you have governors talking about how to encourage more afforded building of affordable housing. so all of these pieces that help not just sustain a middle-class, but i also want to talk about what brings people into the middle-class. i love the fact
4:41 pm
that he's going to talk to steel workers because organized labor has historically been a huge vehicle to get people into the middle-class. a lot of republicans over the years have tried to decimate the support of unions and their power. and joe biden is leaning into that trying to bring, make sure that they're part of the democratic coalition because they have historically not just in terms of wages, but also even in terms of housing, been able to support middle-class voters in terms of the gains among hispanic voters. now, obviously, as harry points out, so there's been a shift, but it's been a shift from biden really. biden really going to a bad place, but now starting to come back how much can that continue? this is that trump was up zero point and now biden's up nine. but biden still way below where he was in the last election is that something that he can really move now tied is that to the border? >> you know, it's interesting because i do feel that there have been voters and we've seen this in some of the polls here and there, that there are real concerns about if you're, if all the support for recent
4:42 pm
migrants and a lot of older migrants saying, well, what about us and even african american voters saying the same thing, but what biden has done is turn and lean into those voters. and i think matters, showing up, matters. and what i call just use a sports reference small ball, like going into the smaller retail politics, not just the big rallies thank going to talk to those voters where they are you know, you get that heuristic. does he care about people like me? and i think more and more voters are able to say that when you marry that too, i think all of these other hot-button issues like reproductive rights and so on. then i see that's where you see that movement. >> as well. thank you very much. next, breaking news united states, announcing new sanctions right now against iran after the unprecedented attack against israel, us ambassador to the united nations, linda thomas-greenfiel d is out front and marjorie taylor greene telling cnn the momentum is on her side to oust speaker johnson >> so this has pickleball with
4:43 pm
e-trade for morgan stanley. we're ready for whatever gets served up. >> didn't get to working in trust >> i'd rather work on saving for retirement college since you'd like to get schooled, has pre-built burned, right? >> i brought in a juror max protein with 30 grams of protein. those who tried me felt more energy and just two weeks here, i'll take that ensure next protein, 30 grams protein one frame, sugar, 25 vitamins and minerals, and a new fiber blend with a prebiotic >> these used cars look the same, but car facts can show how damages affects the value >> they're done as always visible >> were twins stop the paint shop at the new car tax.com identical twins >> when enamel is gone, you cannot get it back, but you can repair it with pronoun will repair it penetrates deep into the two to actively repair acid weakened enamel, i recommend from enamel repair with new pronoun will repair mouthwash. you can enhance that repair beyond brushing. they work great together. >> this tiny home trend not for
4:44 pm
me. now, this is more like it. the same goes for my foot worth why one hands-free with wife fits, get your slip just step in and go without bending down or touching my shoes. white bit hands-free skechers, slip when you have chronic kidney disease there are places you'd like to be like here and here not so much here >> far >> seeker reduces the risk of kidney failure, which can lead to dialysis our sega, can cause serious side effects, including ketoacidosis that may be fatal, >> dehydration, urinary tract, or genital yeast infections hello, blood sugar. a rare life-threatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. stop taking far sega and call your doctor right away. if you have symptoms of this infection and allergic reaction or ketoacidosis when you have chronic kidney disease, it's time to ask your doctor for far
4:45 pm
sika because their places you want to be >> if you can't afford your medication astrazeneca may be able to help alexis show alternate routes >> technology that's ready for the romans lexis and x >> choosing a treatment for your chronic migraine, 15 or more headache days a month each lasting four hours or more can be overwhelming. so ask your doctor about botox look out to prevent headaches and adults with chronic migraine before they even start, it's the number one prescribed branded chronic migraine treatment. so far more than 5 million botox treatments have been given and two over 850,000 chronic migraine patients affects the botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of life-threatening condition, side effects may include
4:46 pm
allergic reactions, neck and injection site in fatigue and headache, don't receive botox if there's a skin infection, tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions and medications including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects >> in a survey, 92% of current users said they wish they talk to their doctor and started botox sooner. so ask you we're doctor if botox is right for you, learn how adds he could help you save on botox >> have an excellent warren g warranty, blurring. she got to go. >> you must have american home shield. >> that, you know, i can tell you our appliances in home jumps are protected, covered repairs and replacements are taken care of. one she never lies off cookie dough american home shield, don't worry, be warranty >> i'm clarissa ward in tel aviv and this is cnn
4:47 pm
>> breaking news, the us tonight announced sing it will impose new sanctions on iran for the attack at launched on israel over the weekend using more than 300 missiles and drones this comes as cnn is learning, israel is weighing whether to launch what is being described as an attack inside iran that's according to us intelligence details at this hour though, are sparse a senior biden administration official says, quote, we would hope that the israelis would give us some morning. any additional move now opens up a series of other possibilities, some of which are quite frightening. upfront now the us ambassador to the united nations, linda thomas-greenfiel d, and she joins me now tonight for this morning in her case from seoul, south korea, where she has just returned from the dmz are rare visit for a us official to obviously one of the world's most heavily armed borders between north and south korea. >> investor greenfield, i want to ask you in crucial questions about that in a moment. first though, israel's response to iran is expected at any time.
4:48 pm
and one possibility i mentioned is a strike being described as a limited strike, unclear what that means, but on iranian soil does the united states support israel striking inside iran >> like i can't comment on what israel's plans are. i will say aaron, that we have been in close contact with the israelis we are encouraging de-escalation, but we absolutely support israel's right to defend itself from this brutal attack on its own territory that we all witnessed at over the weekend we are just learning just moments ago that the us will impose sanctions on iran in the coming days. unclear exactly what those are, but we do understand ambassador the state department says that it has been days since the us and iran actually communicated and no engagement is expected
4:49 pm
when the iranioreign mister is thathe us? and this week i will be interviewing the foreign minister on this program on thursday, ambassador, do you have a message for him >> a he knows what are messages are. we gave him a very strong message in the security council on sunday. we condemn there her attack on israel and we made very, very clear that what they were doing went against all of the security council resolutions in terms of they're using the types of missiles that they were. they were using >> so i don't have a direct message from him that he has not already heard from the us government >> as i mentioned, you went to the dmz today in korea. i want to play part of what you said there some very important words here we have held the doors
4:50 pm
open for meaningful diplomacy and we remain open to dialogue. real productive dialogue without preconditions some of your works there. so crucial ambassador, meaningful diplomacy without preconditions and you emphasized those words. and it brought to mind for me the last time the us in north korea met that of course was the summit in 2018 between then-president trump and kim jong un and singapore when you say dialogue and no preconditions, is president biden open to meeting with kim >> absolutely. we have been clear since the biden administration came on board that we are prepared to have an open dialogue with the north koreans without preconditions. we want to pursue diplomacy i visited the room in the border at the dmz. i saw the table
4:51 pm
with the flags on the table, the chairs empty the table empty they all they have to do is walk through the door. there's a door on their side in that room where they can walk through that door and start those negotiations. they may start at a level of the militaries that are on the ground there, but we're willing to do that at every single level to get to a place where we can find a path to peace and to really address the issues that the people love of a republic of korea have with the constant attacks, the constant missile tests near their border. >> and justin to be clear, when i says president biden open to mediated kim with kim, you started your answer with absolutely. then you went into the details there about that table and i've been there in that table. it is poignant. it's the seats that are empty. but when you say every single level, i just want to be clear that that president biden would
4:52 pm
be open to meeting with kim i'm not going to speculate when and if president biden will have a meeting with >> kim before any meeting like that, could happen. we have to have engagements at other levels. >> and your visit comes just after north korea claimed to have successfully launched a new hypersonic missile obviously, their tests and their arsenal now are central focus the world has just changed with iran launching a massive direct attack on israeli soil with missiles does the united states at this point, ambassador have a full picture of the reality of north korea's arsenal >> we certainly have a good picture. i don't know if we have a full picture. we were very disappointed when the russians vetoed the 17-18 panel of experts resolution that
4:53 pm
allows for reporting on their capabilities. and we will look for other ways to continue that reporting. but they continue over and over to break numerous security council resolutions that they are not being helpfully accountable for because the russians and the chinese provide cover for them in the security council ambassador time discrete i really appreciate your time. thank you. >> thank you very much >> next, the house speaker, mike johnson now facing a bigger threat to his job tonight we will tell you >> this looks like an actual you don't meanwhile, at a vrbo menn other vacation rentals >> aren't what they're cracked up to be. dry one where you know what you get >> so i can take all these trips because priceline has all
4:54 pm
these amazing deals and that's when i said deal on your rais is our jedi deal. >> the deal the deal's army 30, you had me prize >> who are you? i'm in a child >> less, what you really need. life is some fricking torque. >> what >> we're sorry, keep going with torque. get you going what happened to my, inner child gravy, love and acceptance >> how much you love it. he said our job dr. cornered or two. totally torqued out cross silver at fisher investments. we may look like other money managers, but were different. how so? we're. >> a fiduciary >> obligated to act in our client's best interests. so we don't sell any commission-based products, then how do you make money? we have a simple management fee structured, so we do better when our clients do the clients really come first then yes, we
4:55 pm
make them a top priority by getting to know their finances, family, health lifestyle, and more. >> well, maybe we are different at fisher investments were clearly different >> the vietnam war itself. >> your job schutzpass sounds intense >> what are you consuming >> what if i told you that communist slot that's for sure sorry, to see it through your supervisor stream exclusively on max you know, i spent a lot of time thinking about dirt at three in the morning. and he time what people don't know. is that not all dirt is the same. you need dirt with the right kind of nutrients look at this new organic soil from miracle gro, everybody should have it, it worked great for us.
4:56 pm
>> this is as good as gold in any garden. if people only knew that it really is about the dirt your dirt nerd huge turret nerd. >> i'm proud of it >> which like are we operating? asking the right question can greatly >> impact your future? >> sure. you're an orthopedist, >> especially when it comes to your finances? yes. certified financial planner. i'm a cfp >> professional cop professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. that's why it's gotta be a cfb in response to the trade rumors, we keep her in about, uh, what we talk about moment. >> not that's right not it's right. we talking about moving no. thank you. you could use open
4:57 pm
my name is oluseyi and some of my favorite moments throughout my life are watching sports with my dad. now, i work at comcast as part of the team that created our ai highlights technology, which uses ai to detect the major plays in a sports game. giving millions of fans, like my dad and me, new ways of catching up on their favorite sport. 187786 68555 anderson cooper 360. >> next on cnn >> breaking news, more house republicans joining the effort to oust the speaker, mike johnson republican congressman thomas massie today publicly backing marjorie taylor greene's crusade to remove johnson. brianna massey say there are more republicans who
4:58 pm
have not yet publicly come forward yet who will vote with them to oust johnson? >> there are others behind to massie as well >> of >> course, i'll never speak for them, say their names. i think last time it was an extra firmly difficult process it through everybody into chaos for three-and-a-half week is weeks and it really broke our conference but we never really recovered from that this time. it doesn't need to be that way. so i'm being responsible with this decision and allowing people to come to terms and think about it would be the next speaker >> melanie zanona is out front live on capitol hill, so melanie, you've been doing so much reporting on this talking to all the people at the center of it, how much jeopardy is speaker johnson actually in right now? >> while speaker mike johnson finds himself in a very precarious position right now, and that is because of this simple math after friday, which is when republican congressman white gallagher is planning to resign early. johnson can only afford to lose one republican
4:59 pm
on any party-line vote. so what that means is that if this motion to vacate comes to the floor and both green and math i'll see supported as they've said, they would. that means johnson is certainly going to have to rely on democrats to bail him out. johnson though, has been defined, even as he recognizes the embattled role that he he finds himself in. take a listen >> i am not resigning and it is it is in my view and absurd notion that someone would bring a vacate motion when we are simply here trying to do our jobs it is not helpful to the cause. it is not helpful to the country. we need steady leadership, we need steady hand ends at the wheel. look, i regard myself as a war time speaker >> now, greene has not committed to a timeline to forcing a vote on a motion to vacate and part of the reason for that is because she says she wants to give republicans time to find a potential successor so they can avoid the same embarrassing speaker drama that we saw an october, but as of this point, we have not seen
5:00 pm
any evidence that anyone's coalescing behind a potential successor which could work to johnson's advantage. and meanwhile, some democrats are signaling that they might be willing to step in and help save johnson. but other republic, other democrats, excuse me, have so far been keeping their powder dry with house it's minority leader hakeem jeffries saying they need to see the details of johnson's foreign aid plan. but they make any commitments about that, they're going to back the speaker, but really remarkable position that democrats now for the second time this congress could control the fate of the republican speaker, erin, i mean, it is absolutely incredible. and as you say, not fully tipping their hand and he would need them to survive. so ironic, a guy who has refused to give them their ukraine bill up to now, maybe someone they choose to save because they might get i mean, wow, the machinations thank you so much, melanie zanona and showing the power of marjorie taylor greene right now and the hill. >> and thanks so mucto >> all of you for joining us as well. ac30 60 begins right now